Re: Reply to Dr. Roy

[Krishna C Tripathi <krishnact@yahoo.com>]

---------------------------------------------------------------------
Please help make the Manifesto better, or accept it, and propagate it!
---------------------------------------------------------------------
Now I will discuss your statements one by one.
1. "Of course I do. Unlike Mr. Tripathi,  I do not
rely on dictionary.com for my vocabulary."
---So consult the source on which you rely upon and
please let us know the source, positively. 
2. "The term "rabid socialist" is known to me; it
likely  derives from quite archaic British usage of
the late 19th or mid 20th centuries."
---This claim shows how stubburn you are. In stead of
quoting any authentic source you are assuming and
pronouncing that your knowledge is complete and final.

If you have the correct etimology I would be happy to
know it, but am not interested in any of your LIKELY
etimologies.
3. "My objection was to gratuitous rudeness which 
violates IPI's norms."
---It appeared rude to you because you don't know the
correct meaning of this term. You should try to know
how rest of the world uses a particular term before
getting offended by it. Let me tell you one more
thing, you have been one of the most rude persons on
this board. Of course I am rude in this mail but its
you who started it.
4. "I must add a new objection about the anonymity 
being used by Mr. Garg and Mr. Tripathi to make their
rude remarks from behind their yahoo email addresses.
Would they care to identify themselves by name and 
address?"
---Another stupid objection based upon 2 more stupid
assumptions. Let me tell you why they are stupid.
Assumption One: Mr. Tripathi is using yahoo account to
remain anonymous. 
Fact One: Mr. Tripathi( that is me ) is not using
yahoo acount to remain anonymous but,
a) I have some morality left in him which prohibits me
from using official resources for regular personal
usage.
b) I am  not using a fake name. This is my real name.
You can check the IPI data base, my initial memebrship
was with my company account (krishna.tripathi@....)
but I changed to yahoo becasue of large number of
mails coming there.
Assumption Two: The non free mail accounts are always
correct.
Fact Two: It is possible and very easy to write e-mail
with any mail id as sender id. If you want I can start
writing from your iit acount. It shows your ignorance
of SMTP protocol, but since you don't have be a SMTP
expert to contribute positively on this board, I won't
mind that.
5. Rest of your mail is request to teach you english
phrase usage, which you can learn by joining an
English language course. Once you are done, you will
be able to comprehend what is discussed here.

   I have one final suggestion for you, don't write an
objection mail about everything that you don't
understand. Try to learn and understand them.
--- "Dr. Subroto Roy" <sroy@vgsom.iitkgp.ernet.in>
wrote:
>
---------------------------------------------------------------------
> Please help make the Manifesto better, or accept it,
> and propagate it!
>
---------------------------------------------------------------------
> >   The point to be noted is the explanation of this
> > word at dictionary.com it self contains the phrase
> > "rabid socialist", as used by Mr. Garg. Does Dr.
> > Roy have any explanation for this uncalled for
> such
> > ignorance  on IPI?
> 
> Of course I do.   Unlike Mr. Tripathi,  I do not
> rely on dictionary.com
> for
> my vocabulary.  The term "rabid socialist" is known
> to me; it likely
> derives
> from quite archaic British usage of the late 19th or
> mid 20th centuries.
> 
> My objection was to gratuitous rudeness which
> violates IPI's norms.   I
> must
> add a new objection about the anonymity being used
> by Mr. Garg and Mr.
> Tripathi to make their rude remarks from behind
> their yahoo email
> addresses.
> Would they care to identify themselves by name and
> address?
> 
> Would either also care to coin a sentence of his
> choice in which the
> term
> "rabid socialist" is used accurately in the case of
> some Bengali or any
> other Indian?   For example, would he call George
> Fernandes or Jyoti
> Basu or
> Mr. Namboodiripad or Rabi Ray a "rabid socialist"?  
>  If so, why?
> 
> Subroto Roy
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
>
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
> This is the National Debate on System Reform.      
> debate@indiapolicy.org
> Rules, Procedures, Archives:           
> http://www.indiapolicy.org/debate/
>
-------------------------------------------------------------------------


__________________________________________________
Get personalized email addresses from Yahoo! Mail - only $35 
a year!  http://personal.mail.yahoo.com/


--------------------------------------------------------------------------
This is the National Debate on System Reform.       debate@indiapolicy.org
Rules, Procedures, Archives:            http://www.indiapolicy.org/debate/
-------------------------------------------------------------------------